Here is our ‘day by day’ review of the trail from NYC to Saratoga. This is 250 miles of NY State’s impressive 750-mile Empire State Trail network. More pics and videos are posted at https://www.instagram.com/loose.spokes
Overall, the NY Empire State Trail is excellent and well maintained. About 30% takes you on side roads, the rest are rural trails. The trail is mostly paved with some hard-packed gravel and very little loose gravel. We had one cyclist in our group who had a road bike with 25mm road tires and she did just fine. Bigger tires made it easier, especially with wet slippery leaves on the trail.
This was our first organized group tour. We used Gotham Bike Tours as he is local and the trip was very customized. I had tried to plan it myself using Amtrak to help us get up and down the rail corridor, but I found it complicated to find hotel and food services along the trail, plus many of the Amtrak train stations were rural parking lots, miles and miles from the trail.
We are accustomed to planning our own tours in Europe, where bike routes go from town to town, and most towns have train stations.
The United States abandoned rail transport in the early 1900’s and chose to invest in highways instead. So while Europe’s trails follow along existing railways, trails in the U.S. follow along defunct railways.
The Empire Trail is actually a series of smaller trails, each a different name. NY connected them, and the signs and GPS are excellent. We never got lost. Our tour operator (Gotham Bike Tours) provided a customized GPS that got us through detours, traffic, and highlighted sites along the way. He even pointed out things like “This is Ralph Lauren’s horse farm.”
The trail was much more rural than we expected. We didn’t go through many small towns. Some places, you could tell the trail ran near/behind a village, but you had to get off-trail to find a café or restroom.
I was very surprised at how few people were on the trail especially given its proximity to New York City. To compare, we rode the Virginia Creeper Trail on a weekday and there were hundreds of cyclists.
I believe the low usage is due to how rural the trail is. It does not go through many towns. I noticed many parking lots along the way. Locals must drive to the trail to ride it.
The rural nature of this trail makes finding services (hotels, food) a challenge. The gnarley parts almost always involved getting to our hotel. We stayed in chain hotels such as the Hampton Inns which are generally located on or close to highways. The one exception was in Hudson, where we stayed at The Wick, a boutique hotel. They allow bikes in your room but the rooms were much smaller.
It was great riding with a tour, and we had the option to take the SAG to hotels to avoid traffic. We also had more restaurant options—we drove to restaurants as a group. Our tour operator had vetted all hotels and restaurants, reconned the route for any detours/construction, and they provided lunch and rest stops. The lunches were from local independent eateries so we got a ‘taste’ of the local flavors.
Day 1 - Oct 9- NYC to Yonkers 28 miles
We stayed in Yonkers NY and took the train, with our bikes, to Grand Central Station. We connected with other members of our group, and rode down 2nd Avenue to Battery Park which is the official start of the Empire State Trail. We had time to see the Humans of NY exhibit at Grand Central, the 9/11 Memorial, and Little Island Park. Lunch was outside in a park overlooking the river. Our guide runs Gotham Bike Tours and he led us thru NY with its construction, detours, and traffic. Of the 28 miles, about 14-15 were on the protected trail. We rode on streets that had protected bike lines (separated from traffic by a lane of parked cars). The most dangerous part were the delivery e-bikes which are fast by riders who will run through red lights. Lukas, our guide, said to stay far to the left so they could pass on the right; the city streets are mostly one-way.
Jay and I rode the last 5 miles alone during rush hour because we had to stop at a bike shop for a repair. It was surprisingly easy. We’re comfortable riding in traffic in Europe, and we have mirrors and lots of lights for visibility in traffic. We were pleasantly surprised throughout the tour the number of times that traffic stopped to let us cross roads. I felt a lot more respect for cyclists in the northeast than we have in the south, where we live.
Big thanks to Tread Bike Shop in upper Manhattan who did an ‘on-the-spot’ repair and got me back riding. My bike had fallen on the train earlier and I’d broken my cable adjuster. It took just :45 and they only charged us $30. Great folks! They knew we were starting a 6 day tour and they dropped everything to take care of us!
As Interesting as the ride was in NYC, the prettiest part was the Yonkers greenway, it was quite long, about 3-4 miles, and got us thru the congested city traffic. Of course, most hotels are on busy streets so there was no avoiding traffic heading into our Hampton Inn. We managed to stay on sidewalks but they were dicey as well.


Day 2 Yonkers to Brewster, 47 miles
The was a lovely and very rural day of riding. There is a bridge out just outside of Brewster so we had a detour and we had to play “Frogger” with the traffic getting off the New York State Thruway to get to our lovely Comfort Inn. No stoplight crossing a 4 lane highway. Good times!

Day 3 Brewster to Poughkeepsie - 38 miles
The next morning, half of us took the SAG to avoid the highway and carrying bikes up the STAIRS (!) to get to the trail. Jay of course rode it. We met up at a country store called Kobachars and started the trail headed north to the lovely “Walkway Over the Hudson,” which is about a mile-long pedestrian bridge and a tourist attraction. We could see the Nor’Easter coming down the river, so we skedaddled back to Poughkeepsie via the SAG. We chose not to take our life into our own hands by navigating the Thruway traffic into the Hampton Inn in Poughkeepsie…except for Jay who rode the rest of the way to the hotel across a different bridge nearby.


Day 4 Poughkeepsie/New Paltz to Hudson- option to stop at Tivoli (32 or 40 miles)
For days we’d been tracking the Nor’easter. And here it was. A very windy day! Had a rest stop at the Kingston Point Beach where we filmed our best [Weather Channel’s] Jim Cantore imitation of the storm rolling in and the 35 mph winds. Next came the exciting Mid-Hudson Bridge which is 1.5 miles long. Wind gusts est’d at 20-30 mph. Very fast traffic, a bike lane, and a barrier-protected pedestrian lane which was narrow. I walked my bike on the pedestrian lane and it was gnarley. I tried to take a video but the wind practically blew my phone out of my hand. It took me a while to stop shaking. Yes, there was a SAG option but we chose to attempt the bridge. At about mile 32 we came upon a cute town called Tivoli, with cafés and shops. It was everything I needed, and I called called the SAG to pick my scaredy-cat ass up! Jay, of course, rolled on to Hudson, riding solo.

Day 5 Hudson to Albany, 40 miles
If you’re going to have a rainy day on this tour let it be the day you’re in Hudson! We had a great time visiting the galleries and shops. The only person to ride was Jay. He had rain gear and was not about to let weather get in his way. He squeezed every mile he could out of this tour!


Day 6 Albany to Saratoga Springs
We rode directly out of our hotel in downtown Albany. The trail follows the river, parts of the canal, and villages between Albany and Saratoga. To be honest, most of this area is economically depressed, and the towns were rather sad. But the ride ended in Saratoga Springs Park where we sampled the springwater at the many fountains in the park. (Get a map- you can ride around and taste water from several fountains. Surprisingly, they all taste different!) Saratoga Springs is a bustling historic town known for its racetrack and is the summer home to NY’s Opera and Symphony. There’s lots to see and do in Saratoga Springs!


For more photos and videos, https://www.instagram.com/loose.spokes